Where to Get Your Pies This Fall on Long Island


Get your homemade pie fix at any of these local farm stands and bakeries.

Print Email

Photo: Shutterstock.

Nothing says cozy autumn afternoons like fresh baked pie. You can get yours at any of these Long Island shops and farm stands.


Youngs Farms


This farm was founded in 1893. So they’ve been around a while and we assume they know a thing or two about pies. Baking fresh pies on premises their list includes apple, coconut, dark cherry, pear, peach, and many more.


Location: 91 Hegemans Lane, Old Brookville, (516) 626-3955.


Jericho Cider Mill


Apple, blueberry, peach, cherry, raspberry. Mouthwatering list of pies and they’ve been around since 1820! They also have Apple Cider so it makes a perfect autumn visit.


Location: 213 Route 106, Jericho, (516) 433-3360.


Buttercooky Bakery


Huge selection of pies on the menu and a staple in the community since the 1960s. Can’t pick up your order. They deliver!


Locations: Floral Park - 217 Jericho Turnpike, (516) 354-3831; Manhasset - 140 Plandome Road, (516) 627-1600; Huntington - 495 New York Avenue, (631) 424-4034.


Hometown Bake Shop


A bake shop with a focus on great baked goods and a family atmosphere. They’re also opening soon in Patchogue. The pie list includes some interesting flavors like S'mores, Salted Caramel Apple, Salted Caramel Pretzel, Banana Cream, Blueberry Oat, Black Bottom Bourbon, and more.


Location: 2 Little Neck Road,Centerport, (631) 754-7437.


Briermere Farms


Known Island-wide for their pies, they have an amazing pie list. All baked on the farm from scratch.


Location: 4414 Sound Ave., Riverhead, (631) 722 - 3931.


Hallock’s Cider Mill


An old country roadside market making fresh homemade pies and a lot more. The custard coconut looks delish! And the key lime pie gets rave reviews.


Location: 1960 Main Road, Laurel, (631) 298-1140.


Nettie's Country Bakery


Center Moriches. An assortment of pies and donuts! Founded in 2014 by Joe and Jeanette "Nettie" McHeffey.


Location: 366 Railroad Avenue, Center Moriches, (631) 400-9900.


Round Swamp Farm


They carry all the classic fruit crumb pies (Raspberry Peach, Tri-berry, Apple, and more), plus they bake a variety of family recipes!


Location: Bridgehampton - 97 School Street, (631) 296-8078; Montauk - 71 S Elmwood Avenue, (631) 668-8488.


Country View Farm Stand


A third generation family farm stand with a variety of pies to choose from.


Location: 57995 Main Road, Southold, (631) 903-1335.