We surveyed eyeliners regardless of price. We found that bad eyeliners aren’t necessarily cheap, nor are great eyeliners necessarily expensive. This is particularly true of liquid eyeliner—our two top picks cost less than $10. Based on our research, expensive eyeliners are far more likely to have fanbases than cheapies, which meant we had a lot of expensive eyeliner to acquire and then reject. Last but not least, an all-time favorite for anyone who& 8217;s a fan of gel pots. This is absolutely