Suffolk, Nassau Authorities Announce Three People Arrested in Connection with Knifepoint Robbery Streak

Suspects, allegedly responsible for a string of 17 robberies, were arrested by joint Suffolk and Nassau County Police effort.

Print Email

Above are the mug shots of (L to R) Julianna Pantaleone, Paul Drab, and Shane Cashmore, who were arrested and charged in connection with 17 knifepoint robberies.

Photo by: Suffolk County Police Department

Long Island, NY - May 2, 2017 - Suffolk County Police and Nassau County Police have arrested three people in connection with knifepoint robberies that have occurred in both counties since February.
A man armed with a knife entered Carvel, located at 1840 New York Avenue in Huntington Station, and demanded money last night at approximately 9:40 p.m. The employee complied. The man and two other people who assisted him were arrested outside the store by Nassau County Police Robbery Squad and Suffolk County Police Major Case Unit who were conducting a joint investigation. Shane Cashmore, 30, undomiciled, Paul Drab, 26, of Levittown, and Julianna Pantaleone, 31, of Levittown, were arrested and charged with Robbery 1st Degree for the Carvel robbery.
Cashmore has been identified as the knifepoint robber in 17 additional robberies in Suffolk and Nassau Counties. He has been charged in Suffolk County with Robbery 1st Degree for the following robberies:
  • The Barn, located at 370 Hawkins Ave., Lake Ronkonkoma, on April 30
  • Baskin Robbins, located at 4597 Sunrise Highway, Bohemia, on April 19
  • Subway, located at 600 Portion Road, Holbrook, on April 18
  • The Barn, located at 10 Belmont Ave., West Babylon, on April 11
  • Carvel, located at 290 Ronkonkoma Ave., Lake Ronkonkoma, on April 1
  • Subway, located at 1195 Sunrise Highway, Copiague, on March 20
  • Carvel, located at  1075 Montauk Highway, Copiague, on February 13
“These arrests are the result of excellent collaboration between the Suffolk and Nassau County Police Departments. This type of collaboration involves intelligence sharing, daily conversations and meetings and leveraging resources that resulted in the closure of a major case,” Suffolk County Police Commissioner Timothy D. Sini said. “We are glad to bring this spree to an end.”
Cashmore, Drab and Pantaleone are scheduled to be arraigned today at First District Court in Central Islip.
A criminal charge is an accusation. A defendant is presumed innocent until and unless proven guilty.