2020 Guide to Getting Your Holiday Pies


We scoped out a few of the best places to get pies on Long Island.

Print Email

Photo: Shutterstock.

No holiday table is complete without a pie or two (or three) for dessert. We compiled a bunch of the many great places to get pies for your holiday gathering this year.


Crumble Pie Co. - Crumble Pie Co. makes organic crumb pies available for delivery or pick-up. Location: 12 Tiffany Road Oyster Bay Cove, (516) 673-1910.

Hometown Bake Shop - Hometown Bake Shop started with the idea of taking family flavors and putting a twist on the classics. Everything they make is made from scratch with all natural, fresh ingredients. Locations: 2 Little Neck Road, Centerport; 16 Havens Avenue, Patchogue.

Tildas Bake Shop - Tilda's Bake Shop has been providing the baked goods people love for over 59 years, Location: 640 Route 25A, Rocky Point, (631) 744-3762.

Torte Jeff Pie Company - Home Baked Pies and Sweet treats for all. Location: 218 East Main Street Port Jefferson, (631) 456-1532.

Buttercooky Bakery - For over 50 years Buttercooky Bakery has served Long Island residents fresh-baked cookies, pastries and cakes. Locations: Manhasset Bakery, 140 Plandome Road, (516) 627-1600; Floral Park Bakery, 217 Jericho Turnpike, (516) 354-3831; Huntington Bakery, 495 New York Avenue, (631) 424-4034.

Briermere Farms - Known Island-wide for their pies, they have an amazing pie list. All baked on the farm from scratch. Location: 4414 Sound Ave., Riverhead, (631) 965-6080.

Nettie's Country Bakery - An assortment of pies and donuts! Founded in 2014 by Joe and Jeanette "Nettie" McHeffey. Location: 366 Railroad Avenue, Center Moriches.

Round Swamp Farm - They carry all the classic fruit crumb pies (Raspberry Peach, Tri-berry, Apple, and more), plus they bake a variety of family recipes. Locations: 184 Three Mile Harbor Road, East Hampton; 97 School Street, Bridgehampton; 71 S Elmswood Avenue, Montauk; (631) 324-4438.

Country View Farm Stand - A third generation family farm stand with a variety of pies to choose from. Location: 57995 Main Road, Southold.

Youngs Farms - This farm was founded in 1893. So they’ve been around a while and we assume they know a thing or two about pies. Baking fresh pies on premises their list includes apple, coconut, dark cherry, pear, peach, and many more. Location: 91 Hegemans Lane, Old Brookville, (516) 626-3955.