LongIsland.com

Where to get authentic and homemade Mexican food on Long Island

Written by Lon Cohen  |  17. October 2019

We list some of the top authentic Mexican restaurants on Long Island. Whether you want take-out or sit down to a modern Mexican meal, these restaurants will satisfy your urge.

 

Photo Bestio Facebook Page.

 

Bestio

Mexican restaurant with three locations on Long Island in Huntington, Roslyn and West Islip. Has received accolades for its guacamole and margaritas. They say that they carry more than 75 tequilas from Mexico.Locations: 402 New York Ave, Huntington, (631) 549-0100; 1516 Old Northern Blvd., Roslyn, (516) 484-3001; 399 Montauk Hwy, West Islip, (631) 620-3222.

 

Photo: Oaxaca Facebook Page.

 

Oaxaca

Another restaurant in the Alex and Maria dynasty of Mexian restaurants! Opened in 1996, this was their second endeavor. Reviewers five it points for its authentic food and quaint atmosphere. 385 New York Ave., Huntington, (631) 547-1232.

 

Photo: Quetzalcoatl Facebook Page

 

Quetzalcoatl

Owners Alex and Maria wanted to bring authentic Mexican food to Long Island in the 1990s. After opening award-winning restaurants The lil Caboose and Oaxaca. They then expanded to open Quetzalcoatl.A not-so-hidden-gem of a Mexican restaurant in Huntongton village. Two levels of food and fun! 296 Main St, Huntington, (631) 427-7834.

 

Photo: Verde Facebook Page

 

Verde

This restaurant in Bay Shore puts its focus on Mexico City and Oaxacan style food. Main dining room features a live greenhouse, home to over 50 varieties of herbs, peppers and edible garnishes and are all used throughout the bar and kitchen programs.The restaurant was built and designed using mostly reclaimed materials such as old bar wood, barn roofs, recycled brick and repurposed tables and chairs. Serving lunch and dinner 7 days a week with brunch on Sundays from 11am-4pm. Happy Hour every Monday-Friday 3pm-7pm with $5 Margaritas and mixed drinks, $4 beers, $2 off all wines and 1/2 price tacos & quesadillas. 70 E Main St., Bay Shore, (631) 665-6300.

 

Photo: La Fondita Facebook Page (https://www.facebook.com/LaFondita/)

 

La Fondita

Translated to “little kitchen" they say their fare is traditional Mexican food reminiscent of the street food found in markets and taquerias throughout Mexico. They pride themselves on no frills and no attitude authentic Mexican food. Started by the people who brought you Nick & Toni's, Rowdy Hall, and Townline BBQ. Location: 74 Montauk Hwy., Amagansett, (631) 267-8800.

 

Photo: Tocolo Cantina Facebook Page.

 

Tocolo Cantina

Serving classic Mexican dishes prepared with the sophistication of a fine dining restaurant in a casual and approachable manner. Location: 920 Old Country Rd, Garden City, (516) 222-0060.

 

Lucharito's

Touts itself as freshly prepared foods at affordable prices. They also have over 50 kinds of tequilas to choose from. Also visit their other location, Little Lucharitos, in Riverhead. Locations: 119 Main St, Greenport, (631) 477-6666; 487 Main Rd, Riverhead, (631) 779-3681.

 

Photo: Agave Grill Facebook Page

 

Agave Grill

Serving Mexican/American food at the previous Vino N' Vittles location. Reviewers say that the margaritas are “sensational.” Large portions and Try the tacos. Location: 110 Front St., Greenport, (631) 333-2323.

 

Photo: Caracara Facebook Page

 

Caracara Mexican Grill

Authentic and upscale Mexican food for everyone.Enjoy the dining room or their Tequila Lounge. Children's Menu available and football specials during all NFL games. Happy Hour Monday through Friday 4-7pm in the Tequila Lounge. Weekend brunch 11:30am-3pm.  Special prefix dinner menu for $23.95 offered Sunday through Tuesday. Location: 354 Main St, Farmingdale, (516) 777-2272.

 

Photo: Maria's Kitchen Facebook Page.

 

Maria's Kitchen

Owner Maria Serrano serves up authentic Mexican food when you find yourself on shelter island. Tacos, quesadillas, nachos, and more. Take out or eat right there. Location: 55 N Ferry Rd, Shelter Island, (631) 749-5450.

 

Photo by https://www.pexels.com/@chitokan-1072703

 

Little Mexico Bar Restaurant

Mexican and margaritas on the patio. Location: 280 Post Ave, Westbury, (516) 333-2038.

 

Photo by Vinícius Caricatte from Pexels

 

5 de Mayo Mexican

Authentic home-style Mexican cuisine. Happy Hour every night from 4-7pm. Locations: 611 Old Country Road, Westbury (516) 280-7795; Take-out 2350 Jerusalem Ave., North Bellmore, (516) 809-5348.

 

Photo: Mesita Facebook page.

 

Mesita

The name translates to “small table.” They serve authentic, modern, Mexican cuisine in a vibrant atmosphere. Menu features fresh guacamole prepared table-side, Mexican street corn, fire-grilled fajitas, along with burritos, tortas, tacos and many other house-made Mexican dishes. Location: 212B Merrick Road, Rockville Centre, (516) 282-9900.

 

Photo: Homemade Taqueria Facebook Page.

 

Homemade Taqueria

Prides itself on fresh homemade, authentic Mexican food served in a friendly environment to share and enjoy with family and friends. Multiple locations in New York City but only one on Long Island. Location: 243 Fulton Ave. Hempstead, (516) 483-6151.

Copyright © 1996-2019 LongIsland.com & Long Island Media, Inc. All rights reserved.