First Choice Insurance opened its doors in June, 1987 right here on beautiful Long Island. We’ve grown to be one of the premier independent insurance agencies in New York State. While we advertise to reach new clients, we are proud to say more than 70% of our business is referred by satisfied clients. We specialize in personal & commercial lines insurance such as Auto, Homeowners, Business, Commercial, Boat, Flood & Motorcycle. Policies can be written by mail, email, phone, fax & in person.
Why is an independent agent best for you, the consumer? As an independent agent, we have a relationship with 20 or more carriers so we shop the best rate for you. Insurance companies that advertise only quote you with one, theirs! Would you shop at a car lot with one car for sale, or 20? We don’t use voicemail either. When you call us, a person answers the phone. No pushing buttons on your phone for 10 minutes talking to a robot. We will know you by name & you will know all of us by name. Are you tired of calling your insurance company and speaking with a different person every time? That won’t happen here. You’ll ask for people by name & they’ll pick up the phone every time. Maybe we do it the old fashioned way but that’s what it’s all about. People helping people.
Did we mention we have great rates too? Most new clients save about 30% with us…not too shabby! It will take a few minutes to find out if we can save you money. Give us a call & find out for yourself. We can’t wait to talk to you!