LongIsland.com's 2021 Holiday Gift Guide


Find the perfect gift for everyone on your list with our holiday gift guide!

Print Email

Stuck on what to get all the people on your holiday gift list? LongIsland.com can help! We’ve curated some great gift ideas. Whether you need a gift for your parents, children, spouse, coworker, or your picky friend who seems to have everything, we have you covered. So get your list together and start shopping – online and right here on Long Island!


Fine Jewelry

Fortunoff Fine Jewelry

Surprise someone special with something that sparkles from Fortunoff Fine Jewelry, New York’s go-to source for fine jewelry since 1957. From elegant necklaces, bracelets, and earrings to unique engagement rings (ready to pop the question this holiday?) you’ll find a large selection of quality jewelry at prices to suit every budget. Fortunoff has a no worries return policy and will gladly exchange or refund your purchase within 30 days of the receipt date.

Shop online in your pajamas at FortunoffJewelry.com and if you need assistance, connect with them to speak with a personal shopper to help you find the RIGHT gift.


Holiday Collectibles
Hicks Nurseries
100 Jericho Tpke., Westbury

Hicks Nurseries in Wesbury is New York’s Christmas authority and a magical wonderland. It’s Long Island’s largest Christmas store and a beautiful place to get your shopping done while experiencing the joys of the holidays.

Give a holiday collectible that will become a treasured family heirloom to be passed down through generations. Hicks carries hand-crafted figurines and ornaments such as Annalee® Figures, Byers’ Choice Carolers® and Christopher Radko® Ornaments. You’ll also find a large selection of Christmas Villages from Department 56®.

Have a gardening enthusiast on your holiday gift list? Help them enhance their green thumb with gardening supplies from Hicks, or give them a stunning indoor plant or a unique statement-making flower pot.


Design-Your-Own Kits

Fun Stuff Toys
3639 Merrick Road, Seaford

Give your creative kids Design-Your-Own Dream Canopy or Wall Mural Kits. You’ll find those and you’ll find lots of awesome sets and toys at Fun Stuff Toys in Seaford. Fun Stuff Toys has been a premier Long Island toy store for 30 years. Stop by or shop online for arts and crafts and science kits, dolls, games, LEGOs, and more. You can even create a wish list online to send to family and friends.



Foodie Card
Foodie Card
Dine with a purpose. The Foodie Card is the perfect gift for your foodie friends and family. They will receive 10% off for all dine-in restaurants (including liquor) all year long at participating restaurants in the tri state area. Even better? For each card purchased a full day of meals is donated to someone in need through The Foodie Card’s partnership with Island Harvest. Use code LICOM and save $10!


New York Bagel of the Month Subscription

New York Bagel of the Month Club

Give the gift of fresh, authentic New York bagels from Long Island’s famous Bagel Boss. With a Bagel of the Month Club subscription package, 13 bagels will be delivered to you or your recipient every month. It’s a unique and delicious gift that keeps on giving on all year long. Bagel Boss bagels are produced by 6th generation bagel and bialy bakers, using old world recipes from Bialystok, Poland! Once rolled, the bagels are boiled, baked, cooled, packed and shipped that same morning. Shipping is FREE.

The New York Bagel of the Month Club also has many bagel packages available for one-time purchase. Send a package of assorted bagels, bialys, homemade cream cheese and bakery items, and more.


Anthony Scotto Restaurant Gift Cards 

Anthony Scotto restaurant gift cards are always in excellent taste. Gift cards are sent in a sleek gift envelope and can conveniently be used at the following restaurants:

Blackstone Steakhouse, 10 Pinelawn Rd, Melville. Blackstone is an architectural masterpiece that offers an unforgettable dining experience. Its renowned cuisine includes exotic cuts of beef, fresh seafood flown in from Hawaii and Holland, wonderful seasonal dishes and creative homemade desserts.

Insignia, 610 Smithtown Bypass, Smithtown. A premier Long Island Steakhouse featuring the finest prime dry-aged steaks, fresh seafood and a dazzling array of sushi creations, all served up in a chic, elegant atmosphere that is also a feast for the eyes.

One10, 569 Broadhollow Rd, Melville. Modern Italian Steakhouse set in an awe-inspiring 14,000-square-foot space that exudes a contemporary style. Cuisine is anything but typical, with a variety of dishes made from the finest locally sourced ingredients. Enjoy everything from prime dry-aged steaks, hand-made pastas and Italian classics to Pat LaFrieda burgers, chops, and the freshest seafood.

Opus Steakhouse, 4 Old Jericho Turnpike, Jericho - A chic, contemporary, restaurant with 25-foot cathedral ceilings and dazzling panoramic glass-wall vistas that spill out to lush gardens and terraces with plush outdoor seating. Its exciting menu features incredible dishes and specials that will be sure to suit every taste bud.  Enjoy succulent steakhouse classics and seafood including a sushi bar.

Rare650, 650 Jericho Turnpike, Syosset. One of Long Island’s premiere Prime Steak and Sushi Restaurants, Rare650 offers an exceptional dining experience. Its menu is truly unique, combining the finest 45 Day prime dry-aged steaks with amazing sushi creations and the freshest seafood. Plus, the sommelier can help you select the perfect wine to complement your meal from a 500 bottle, award-winning wine list.

Bijou, 400 Broadhollow Road, Melville,- coming soon!  Give a gift card and allow your recipient to be among the first to experience this distinctive addition to the Anthony Scotto restaurant lineup. 

The Ainsworth Gift Card

210 Merrick Road, Rockville Centre

The Ainsworth offers a new take on classic American fare favorites, signature cocktails, and visually stimulating décor, culminating in the ultimate drinking and dining experience. The savory and unique dining menu touches upon everything from brunch and lunch to dinner and catering. Known for their steaks, skewers, oysters, brunch, fish tacos and their famous 24k Gold Wings and Mac and Cheeseburger.

Dang BBQ Gift Cards

Islip - 174 Islip Ave

Seaford - 3864 Merrick Road

Hauppauge -Simplay Hauppauge, 180 Commerce Dr.

Looking for a gift for the BBQ enthusiast? A Dang BBQ gift card is a no-brainer. Dang BBQ offers an impressive abundance of dishes, flavors, and ingredients, from savory dishes such as smoked pork and hickory burgers to a wide range of desserts and milkshakes, plus a tap and drink bar. They smoke the meat for half the day to give it a strong, mouthwatering taste customers love. Visit one of their locations in Seaford, Islip, and within Simplay in Hauppauge or order a gift card online.

Sangria 71 Gift Cards

Commack: 1095 Jericho Turnpike

Island Park: 4585 Austin Blvd

Williston Park: 71 Hillside Avenue

Located in Commack, Island Park, and Williston Park, Sangria 71 is a family style restaurant specializing in the Flavors of Spain. It offers a fine assortment of tapas, steaks, chicken, seafood as well as savory family-style paellas, superb sangrias, and a fine selection of Spanish wines in a festive, casual atmosphere.



Season Passes and Memberships
If you know someone loves a certain event, museum or activity, why not get them a season pass or membership? Here are some ideas:

Long Island Children’s Museum Premium Membership

The Long Island Children’s Museum in Garden City is a learning space devoted to the busy work of play. It features 14 interactive exhibits plus live theater, art spaces and daily activities to provide hours of discovery for children of all ages.

A Premium Family membership which costs $200, includes free admission all year long, free and discounted guests, and more. There are lower membership levels to choose from as well.

Adventureland Season Pass

Thrill seekers will appreciate an Adventureland Season Pass and get unlimited admission and unlimited rides all of 2022! Regular pass is $144.99; 2022 Parent Season passes are available for a discounted rate of $74.99.


Long Island Ducks Season Passes

Cheer on Long Island’s own minor league baseball team! Season pass holder benefits include: 

  • The best pricing on Ducks tickets, with discounts up to 20% OFF the box office price.

  • A budget-friendly, no-interest EZ Pay payment plan program

  • Guaranteed same great seat for every home game (fireworks shows, premium giveaway nights, etc.)

  • Tickets to all Ducks home playoff games

  • Access to the "Duck Club" restaurant/bar on the suite level

  • An exclusive VIP red carpet entrance at the West Gate

  • Early entrance into the ballpark (15 minutes prior to the general public), giving you the first chance to receive that game's giveaway item

  • 10% discount on all official team merchandise at the Waddle In Shop

  • A FREE season ticket holder VIP gift

  • The opportunity to be featured on scoreboard during games as part of the "Meet the Flockers” recognition program

  • An opportunity to make a tax-deductible ticket donation to "Tickets for Kids" for those less fortunate, or turn in unused tickets via alternate exchange programs

  • FREE parking for all games at Fairfield Properties Ballpark

Puzzle Break LI Gift Certificate
Puzzle Break Long Island
180 Michael Drive, Syosset

Give family and friends who have everything an opportunity to be trapped in a room for 60 minutes and a chance to escape. Do they have what it takes to escape the lost temple, midnight carnival, or underwater laboratory? A Puzzle Break LI Gift Certificate is a fun and unique gift that will have your recipients solving clues, decoding locks, while having a lot of fun and making memories. Gift certificates can be purchased online.