A beloved Long Island breakfast and lunch hotspot, Gabby’s Gourmet Bagelatessen, has announced its closure after an impressive 25-year run. Located on the bustling Jericho Turnpike, the shop has been a fixture in the Woodbury community—delighting bagel lovers and newcomers alike with its wide-ranging menu and warm, welcoming atmosphere .
A Community Landmark Bids Farewell
Since opening its doors in 2000, Gabby’s quickly became more than just a culinary stop—it was a local institution. Known for crafting everything from classic plain and everything bagels to house-made spreads and sandwiches, it served breakfast, lunch, and even dinner, capturing hearts with its consistency and quality .
What’s Next—and When?
While the announcement confirmed that the shop will be shutting down, details remain scarce. To date, neither the owners nor staff have disclosed the closing date or the reasons behind the decision . However, the community knows the end is imminent. One thing is clear: an auction of the entire shop’s contents is scheduled for Tuesday, September 9 .
From Community Hub to Final Farewells
For many residents, Gabby’s was woven into daily routines—from early-morning runs for freshly brewed coffee and warm bagels to midday sandwich breaks or dinners on the go. A handful of long-time customers shared their sentiments:
-
“I’ve been coming here since college—wake-up coffee and bagel every Tuesday,” said one local.
-
“Sunday mornings won’t be the same without Gabby’s everything with scallion cream cheese,” lamented another.
Gabby’s wasn’t just a food stop—it was a gathering place for families, friends, and neighbors to connect over comfort food. Its closure reminds us of the things we may take for granted until they’re gone.