Tellers Restaurant

Weather Alert  

"Coastal Flood Statement" * locations...low lying coastal areas along western Long Island Sound. * Positive tidal departures...1/2 to 1 ft. * Timing...around the times of high tide tonight. * Impacts...brief minor flooding of the most vulnerable Waterfront and shoreline roads. -- Saturday May.27 17,03:24 PM

Tellers Restaurant

605 Main Street
Islip, NY
Phone: (631) 277-7070

Centrally located in Islip, Long Island, Tellers Restaurant offers quality food, excellent service and an exclusive eating atmosphere. Tellers Restaurant is proud of its "true" American chophouse menu, complete with American cuisine and delectable local seafood. Diners will feel pampered as soon as they enter Tellers Restaurant while walking under a canopied entrance that is situated in the middle of scenic gardens with beautiful architectural details. As if that weren't enough, diners will feel that much more impressed once they situate themselves in Tellers stunning dining room. Deemed as "one of the most strikingly beautiful dining rooms on the Island" by the New York Times, Tellers' dining room features 32 foot ceilings and gigantic windows that stream in beautiful sunlight during the day. In the evening the dining room is lit with soft, romantic lighting which helps to accentuate the elegant floral arrangements that can be witnessed at any time. The Gold Bar of Tellers Restaurant is also a fun and inviting space to relax with friends and family. The bar exudes a more club like feel that goes along with Tellers Restaurant's modern yet classic vibe. A Banquet Room is also available for special events such as family reunions, celebrations or corporate gatherings. The Banquet Room is also elegantly decorated with charming artwork, modern lighting and comfortable seating. Call them today to make a reservation, or to schedule your next affair.

Visit us on the web at TellersChopHouse.com

Details

Features

  • Private Room Available, Bar / Lounge

Hours Not Specified

Contact Info

605 Main Street
Islip, NY 11751
(631) 277-7070
Visit Website Email Restaurant

Photos
Reviews
Hoorible experience

Hoorible experience

Mar 15th, 2015 12:23 PM

Went there for a private party last night. Party of 15 people, and 4 ordered lobster, mind you that a 2 lb lobster was part of a $100 pre-fix, without drinks. When my lobster came back, it had no lobster tail and hardly any lobster in it. When I asked the man in charge, who instantly had an attitude, he said that was part of the $100 menu, and it is what it is. Finally, about 45 minutes later, they brought me a real lobster dinner, but by that time everyone had started on dessert. I asked to wrap it up , and brought it home. I eat at all the finest restaurants on Long Island, as well an Manhattan, and this experience has left me to not only never eat at Teller's again, but to tell all my friends as well as business associates to never go there. It is 5 star prices with a 2 star meal. Never again.

Long Lines

Long Lines

Jul 30th, 2013 10:44 AM

The food was good but I suggest you get a reservation because we had to wait sometime before we could get a table. The lunch special was a real bargain, Tellers really delivers good food at great prices. If you like fresh salad this is the spot.

awesome French fries

awesome French fries

Jul 30th, 2013 10:01 AM

I like Tellers as it is a very nice family restaurant that actually makes their own French fries. This is a huge plus for me as I like the fresh taste. Burgers and fries along with other dishes makes Tellers very popular.

good but not great

good but not great

Jul 29th, 2013 11:34 AM

I have to admit, I have had better. The food is pretty good but nothing as amazing as I would have thought after reading many reviews. The prices are a bit expensive.

Good To The Last Bite

Good To The Last Bite

Jul 24th, 2013 11:18 AM

For me Tellers Restaurant is always A good to the last bite place to dine. I’m always happy with the food they serve. The restaurant has an easy yet elegant atmosphere to it. For sure I will be stopping by again soon.

yummy seafood

yummy seafood

Jul 24th, 2013 10:14 AM

This is our familys favorite restaurant including the kids. I love all their seafood expecially their scallops. The kids love the shrimp but of course my hubby only orders the steak. Great family restaurant with a large vareity on their menu.

delicious

delicious

Jul 22nd, 2013 03:03 PM

The main course was absolutely delightful. The service was very nice and everyone was very genuine and kind. highly recommend.

Sweet

Sweet

Jul 22nd, 2013 11:47 AM

Tellers Restaurant is incredible and the people who work here are very nice. Every time I dine here they always treat me special. By the way I give this place all A’s and you will to.

sunday price fixed menu

sunday price fixed menu

Jul 19th, 2013 10:52 AM

We come here every Sunday. The service is very friendly. We have tried everything on the menu. Our favs under the first course are lump crabcakes and Tellers Baked Clams while the second course favs are Tellers Delmonico and the Roasted Half Chicken.

wonderful scallops

wonderful scallops

Jul 16th, 2013 10:47 AM

I love Tellers. I enjoy their beef wellington and their burgers, however, their scallops are truly heavenly. The staff go above and beyond to make your dining experience perfect. Will come back more often.

Sold

Sold

Jul 15th, 2013 11:09 AM

The craftsmanship of your bar is amazing, I love stopping by every time I am in town to have a few cocktails there. Personally I always order your Black Label Burger with steak fries and the Applewood Smoked Bacon you put on the burgers is out of site!!!

Great catering

Great catering

Jun 13th, 2013 03:30 PM

I ordered private catering for 40 people for a small wedding reception event for my own wedding. It was pricey, but the atmosphere was so much more intimate than what we would've found at a standard wedding reception venue. The service we received was also way above standard, and we were both so happy we decided to host the reception at Tellers. All of our guests commented afterward on how impressed they were with the service and the food, and how many of them wished their own wedding receptions has been hosted somewhere as nice!

Wine Night

Wine Night

Jun 13th, 2013 03:28 PM

I think that was what they called the three course dinner night - it was on Tuesday. The dinner costs $50, and the menu changes every week. The night I went, they had some kind of really amazing beef dish with turnips. The appetizer was a type of quesadilla, also incredible, and for dessert there were cookies. Normally I would not think cookies would be suitably exciting for a fine dining night, but in this case they really were quite spectacular. I would do it again in a heartbeat, and I know this is exactly where I'm bringing my new girlfriend for our one month anniversary dinner in a week!

Best mac n' cheese!

Best mac n' cheese!

May 22nd, 2013 02:46 PM

My favorite food in the world is macaroni and cheese, typically considered a kiddie dish, but once in a while you find it in the "adult" menu, and Tellers is definitely a restaurant for grownups. This is fine dining at its best, and they have not one, but TWO entries for mac n' cheese on their menu! The five cheese is really scrumptious, but the lobster macaroni and cheese is just -divine-. Two of my favorite things in the world combined. Where else are you going to find macaroni and cheese that is that exquisite? It's on the menu as a side dish, but I totally just get a couple of orders of it and call it good.

Elegant dining

Elegant dining

May 22nd, 2013 02:43 PM

This restaurant is one of my favorite places to be. I can't quite define the ineffable quality of the place that makes it so much superior to other fine dining establishments on the island, but it definitely seems to have a little something extra going for it. The decor is quite simple, in its way, but it is very elegantly put together, and the result is comfort and modern sophistication. The food is as sophisticated as the restaurant's design, and likewise, the menu may seem simple at a glance, but the sophistication of the dishes lends something more to the food than what you might initially expect. The filet mignon is some of the best in town. Don't miss out on one of Long Island's gems!

Great steak and scallops

Great steak and scallops

May 13th, 2013 01:47 PM

I've eaten at a lot of steak houses on LI, but I have to say that Tellers is the one I go back to again and again. I am not sure which I enjoy more - their steak, or their scallops. I've been to a lot of restaurants which don't know how to do scallops. If you even slightly undercook or overcook them, they get spongy or chewy and really strange. I've ordered them four times here and been amazed at how perfect they are every single time. I do have to say though, watch out if you have a gift card. Do not order a special. If you do, the gift card will not apply, and you'll have to pay for it out of pocket, which won't come cheap. They are less than communicative about these things, and I found that incredibly irritating the time it happened to me. With everything else being what it is, I'll forgive it. Just don't make the same mistake I did.

Impressive

Impressive

Sep 19th, 2012 01:59 PM

My wife and I celebrated our anniversary dinner at your restaurant and just wanted to say you made the evening perfect. We really were impressed with the Gold Bar where we shared a bottle of wine before dinner and the Dining room was amazingly elegant. We both had your Filet Mignon which was perfect and everyone there were very nice.

Amazing Food, Excellent Service.

Amazing Food, Excellent Service.

Aug 09th, 2012 11:00 AM

I have been to many steakhouses on Long Island, and I have to say - Tellers truly blew me out of the water. The beef wellington was amazing, the side dishes were phenomenal, & the staff was very attentive. As we waited for our main course, they brought us many appetizers - delicious bread & hand cut fries. My father ordered a piece of cheesecake, and it was literally enough for him, myself & my sister to share. It was very expensive, but I'd like to go back again for another special occassion.

Add Your Review

 

 

 

Be sure you've read our Terms of Service
You may not post any unlawful, threatening, defamatory, obscene or other material that would violate the law. All comments should be respectful of other authors and commenters. You are solely responsible for your own comments, the consequences of posting those comments, and the consequences of any reliance by you on the comments of others

 

Map & Directions