Weather Alert  

"Areal Flood Advisory" The National Weather Service in Upton NY has issued a * Flood Advisory for... southern Fairfield County in southern Connecticut... Middlesex County in southern Connecticut... New Haven County in southern Connecticut... western New London County in southern Connecticut... Nassau County in southeastern New York... western Suffolk County in southeastern New York... * until 730 am EDT * at 427 am EDT...Doppler radar indicated heavy rain that will cause minor flooding in the advisory area. Up to one inch of rain has already fallen. Additional rainfall of up to locally 1 to 2 inches is expected over the area. This additional rain will cause minor flooding in urban and poor drainage areas. Precautionary/preparedness actions... Do not drive your vehicle into areas where the water covers the roadway. The water depth may be too great to allow your car to cross safely. Move to higher ground. Please report flooding to your local law enforcement agency when you can do so safely. Lat...Lon 4128 7199 4120 7286 4064 7304 4056 7377 4074 7370 4083 7376 4103 7333 4116 7337 4112 7352 4149 7337 4147 7331 4149 7333 4160 7294 4156 7295 4154 7285 4164 7263 4165 7250 4158 7247 4159 7239 4170 7225 Maloit -- Monday May.30 16,06:24 AM

Hofstra Educator Challenges Common Core Reading Standards

Hofstra University Social Studies Educator Alan Singer says there is a serious flaw in Common Core.

Print Email

In a recent blog post, Hofstra University Social Studies educator Alan Singer made a compelling argument challenging the core of Common Core State Standards for English Language Arts.

Singer contends that there is a serious flaw in the Common Core reading standards resulting from “the ideological point of view about literacy and learning of those who developed it.” The flaw, he points out, centers on uncertainty about the true meaning of a document.

The Common Core College and Career Readiness Anchor Standards for English Language Arts aver that deep meaning is imbedded in the text of a reading passage, primary source document or text alone, apart from its history or the context in which it was written. Consequently, Common Core standards require students to:

  • "Read closely to determine what the text says explicitly and to make logical inferences from it; cite specific textual evidence when writing or speaking to support conclusions drawn from the text."
  • "Determine central ideas or themes of a text and analyze their development; summarize the key supporting details and ideas."
  • "Analyze how and why individuals, events, or ideas develop and interact over the course of a text."

Singer, on the other hand, believes there is no “universal timeless interpretation of a text.” He asks, “Is deep meaning inherent in a text, as the national Common Core standards claim, or is meaning created through the interaction of the reader with a the text because we can never really know exactly what an author from a different time period or who lived under different circumstances intended?”

In order to demonstrate his point, Singer directed his readers to a 15-minute video entitled “Close Reading of Text” produced by David Coleman, a leading author and proponent of the national Common Core standards. The video, based upon Dr. Martin Luther King’s “Letter from Birmingham Jail,” offered a sample set of reading lessons for middle school students in alignment with the Core Standards in literacy.

“Predicting what’s in a text before you read it is not an essential college and career ready skill,” Coleman said. Rather than providing students with background information or guidance before reading a text, he said students could be offered a “mini generic reading strategy that could include discussion about “main idea” or “cause and effect.”

“Because in this type of teaching,” Coleman continued, “you are constantly challenging students to explore what they can do without any help or scaffolding at all.”

Through careful study of the text, King, himself, Coleman contends, would explore the agenda for the students telling them what is important.

Contrary to Coleman’s ideas about what literary instruction should look like, Singer reinforced his view about the importance of understanding the historical content of a document by quoting Associate Justice William Brennan, who in 1985 said, “We current Justices read the Constitution in the only way that we can: as Twentieth Century Americans. We look to the history of the time of framing and to the intervening history of interpretation. But the ultimate question must be, what do the words of the text mean in our time. For the genius of the Constitution rests not in any static meaning it might have had in a world that is dead and gone, but in the adaptability of its great principles to cope with current problems and current needs. What the constitutional fundamentals meant to the wisdom of other times cannot be their measure to the vision of our time. Similarly, what those fundamentals mean for us, our descendants will learn, cannot be the measure to the vision of their time.”

Singer argues that meaning is debated, not uncovered, and that we interpret text based upon information we gather from what we read and from the world. Based upon our experiences and social positions, Singer says, we may arrive at different interpretations about the deeper meaning of a text.

“A cold close reading of text is never sufficient to discover meaning unless we also take into account the “context” or history of the document and its implications for the present and future,” Singer said. “This is a major reason that Common Core is seriously flawed,” he added.

What’s your opinion? Include your comments below or on our Long Island Living Discussion Forum.

[Source: The Huffington Post, Common Core Standards, Engage NY]


Video via Engage NY.