Bay Shore Restaurants - Long Island New York Restaurants, NY

Dining out is something that many locals love to do, and thankfully Bay Shore is packed with plenty of great eateries from quick and casual to upscale fine dining – perfect for grabbing a bite on the go, or planning a romantic night on the town. No matter what your palate craves, Bay Shore's got you covered with a wide variety of cuisine types, and options to suit every budget and occasion – whether you've got the kids in tow, or you're looking to enjoy a meal with that special someone. Whether you're in the mood to grab a few sushi rolls, or you are craving a slice of New York pizza, Bay Shore's diverse restaurants offer everything from a sit down meal to a quick bite. Head over to's Restaurant Section for all of the best local dining island-wide!

Results 1 - 12 of 20

Restaurants in Bay Shore, New York


Captain Bill's Restaurant

122 Ocean Ave , Bay Shore - NY (Map)
Treat those you love to casual, yet elegant waterfront dining on the Great South Bay at Captain Bill's, where you can savor the spectacular ...
Cool Water...

Cool Water Grill

25 Bayview Avenue , Bay Shore - NY (Map)
  Cool Water Grill is a delectable restaurant in Bay Shore. Cool Water has been in operation for over 7 years and doesn’t show ...
Captree Cov...

Captree Cove Restaurant & Catering

3500 East Ocean Parkway , Bayshore - NY (Map)
Captree Cove is a beacon of excellence in seafood on the South Shore of Long Island.
Catch 22

Catch 22

1701 Sunrise Hwy , Bayshore - NY (Map)
Catch 22 is a seafood restaurant in Bay Shore.
Dock Pizza

Dock Pizza

60 Bay Walk , Kismet - NY (Map)
Dynasty Cafe

Dynasty Cafe

1895 Union Blvd , Bay Shore - NY (Map)
Dynasty Cafe in Bay Shore emulates the quintessential midwest diner.
El Apretador

El Apretador

1531 Brentwood Rd , Bay Shore - NY (Map)
El Apretador specializes in South American and Latin American cuisine.

Homemade Chinese Kitchen

3 Candlewood Rd # 2 , Bay Shore - NY (Map)
Icy Kid

Icy Kid

9 Cleveland Ave , Bay Shore - NY (Map)
Icy Kid serves delicious ice creams and frozen yogurtsin Bay Shore.
Kismet Inn

Kismet Inn

1 Oak St , Kismet - NY (Map)
Kismet Inn is a popular American-style eatery on Fire Island offering great meals in the warm season.
Milk & Suga...

Milk & Sugar Cafe

49 W Main St , Bay Shore - NY (Map)
Milk and Sugar Cafe is a popular breakfast and brunch eatery on Main Street in Bay Shore.

Mitsui Japanese Restaurant

1 W Main St , Bay Shore - NY (Map)
Mitsui Japanese Restaurant and Lounge in Bay Shore serves authentic japanese cuisine in a casual dining atmosphere.
Open Feedback Dialog